MSX 200 or ASM G3

[jb61264]

I have the opportunity locally to pick up either one of these skimmers used...which one do you think would be best for my 75 mixed reef with a 55 sump/fuge?

[Tigé21v]

I have the G3 with a recirc mod on a 90, 200g total water volume. pulls out lots of stuff. Very happy with it.

[Amoore311]

MSX200 by far.

[USC-fan]

<a href=showthread.php?s=&postid=15463691#post15463691 target=_blank>Originally posted</a> by Amoore311
MSX200 by far. yea. not even close.

[scott11]

i had the G3, then I got the MSX---the MSX is better in every way.

[skimmy]

no comparison at all, SWC/MSX totally outperforms ASM's, and build quality is twice that of ASM.

[jb61264]

Well...I just bought an MSX 200 with the Sicce pump that is about 3-4 months old for $150...guy was getting out of the hobby locally and just wanted to get rid of it. Did I get a good deal?

[nikon187]

yes you did. The sicce pumps pulls triple the air of a sedra on the G series making it a no comparison.

[ILoveSeahorses]

+1 MSX 200

[metalmulisha]

+ on MSX or I love my octopus extreme 200 with the purple pinwheel. That mod made a HUGE diffrence. I think it was best bang for the buck. Acutally best bang for the buck would be the octopuse extreme cones that are coming out!

[Garage1217]

Great deal, MSX200 FTW