What Tang?

[celamb89]

I really like tangs but what tang would you recommend for a 130gal (4.5' foot length) tank. I really like tangs but I also like to keep a good enviroment, i dont want to add a tang that will be unhappy in the tank, so I wanna know if there is if any tang that could be in this tank. I currently have a redtoothed tiggerfish, ocellaris, six line wrasse and 2 LTA anemones.

[Beblebe]

Tangs need a 6 foot lengh on a tank. That's what everyone has told me. They also say you could get by with a Yellow Tang or Kole Tang in a shorter tank. It all depends on the fish though.

[celamb89]

Tangs need a 6 foot lengh on a tank. That's what everyone has told me. They also say you could get by with a Yellow Tang or Kole Tang in a shorter tank. It all depends on the fish though.

I've also read that tangs need 5-6 foot long tanks but I didnt think all tangs did. I thought maybe I could add a yellow tang or yellowtail purple tang which I would really like as well as a Kole tang as you said.
I dont want a tang that will be miserable in my tank but I want to add a happy swimmer

[Beblebe]

Sorry I changed it right before I posted but it used to say most in front of tangs. But yes, 90% of tangs need a 6 foot tank (I'm no expert but this is what everyone has told me)

[prickles]

this thread has an "expert's" opinion on MIN tank sizes. This might help.

http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=739380

[celamb89]

this thread has an "expert's" opinion on MIN tank sizes. This might help.

http://reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=739380

I did read a part of that thread before. The list stated shows several tangs that will do ok in a 100+ tank, saying that a 125g tank is expected to be at least 2m (5ft). Im looking to introducing the tang to a 130g that is 1.4m x 0.6m x 0.6m (4.5 ft length) so could I try to introduce a yellow tang or a yellowtail purple tang? or is it not even worth the shot?

[slk55r]

I have to say I"m not partial to the purple tang. I got one and it was super aggressive. Of course I might have just got a mean one.

[prickles]

I don't think anyone here can actually mindread fishes. That being said, I have kept tangs in a 110T (4'w) for a year or so and they looked happy.

If you are planning on within the next 1-2 years getting a bigger tank, then I personally would do it. BTW I think 2m=6ft.

[Ding2daDong]

convict tang, chevron tang, blue tang, yellow tang, purple tang, tomini tang, lavender tang, sailfin tang, and probably a few others that I missed.

Just pick one or a couple that you like and will get along. The whole 6' rule thing is for when/if they actually reach full size. Most tangs are purchased around 3" and you shouldn't have a problem with size until they reach 6-7" which will usually take years.

hth

-Matthew

[SMOOTHIE]

If you are looking at grazers I would suggest a chevron and a dwarf angel.
Wrasses are also ALOT of fun to watch searching around your reef

[StripestheEel]

convict tang, chevron tang, blue tang, yellow tang, purple tang, tomini tang, lavender tang, sailfin tang, and probably a few others that I missed.

Just pick one or a couple that you like and will get along. The whole 6' rule thing is for when/if they actually reach full size. Most tangs are purchased around 3" and you shouldn't have a problem with size until they reach 6-7" which will usually take years.

hth

-Matthew

Convict, okay
Chevon - possibly okay
blue tang - will soon outgrow
yellow tang - okay
purple tang - okay
tomini - okay
sailfin - will outgrow

Choose a fish that best fits in with your current tank, not your future ambitions. Based on my experience I would suggest a yellow, purple or kole.

The kole will probably be the best addition algae control wise.

[bglegs]

I had a purple tang (about 4") in a 55 gal for 4 years til I upgraded to a 6' tank.He did very well,I even moved 800 miles with him.He is a very hardy fish.:bounce3:

[TampaReefer79]

I had a purple tang (about 4") in a 55 gal for 4 years til I upgraded to a 6' tank.He did very well,I even moved 800 miles with him.He is a very hardy fish.:bounce3:

But this is not advised.

[michealprater]

My recommendation would be a Tomini as it stays rather small.

[anbosu]

Based on past posts from other people purple tangs can be aggressive in smaller setups. A yellow tang would work well, as would a mimic tang.

[TampaReefer79]

In a 4.5' tank, the tomini or kole would be your best bet. I wouldn't (personally) put a yellow tang and especially not a mimic tang in this tank.

[celamb89]

If you are planning on within the next 1-2 years getting a bigger tank, then I personally would do it. BTW I think 2m=6ft.
LOL ur right 2m = 6ft, miss typed sorry.

As long as the tang goes thanks for all the suggestions! reading all the inputs I think Im in between the purple tang and the kole tang. Ill have to sleep on it and read a little more on this guys. I like the look of the purple tang better but
Choose a fish that best fits in with your current tank, not your future ambitions. Based on my experience I would suggest a yellow, purple or kole.

The kole will probably be the best addition algae control wise.

The algae control keeps the kole in my mind so, I guess Ill have to make a decision.

Does anyone have any experiences to share with this 2 tangs? (kole and purple yang)

Thanks for the posts!

[Btortorelli]

I have a kole and a blonde naso in my 135

[celamb89]

Im starting to lean towards the kole tang. I believe it will be more peaceful and will eat some of the algae. I guess Ill start out with this guy.

[lostintheocean]

kole or tomini, tomini are very pretty with the "flame fin" also cheveron are pretty and smaller but pricy.

[celamb89]

Will tomini and cheveron tangs also eat algae like the Kole tang? Cheveron looks nice but I will have to find one :S.
I like the fact that Kole will eat algae so wanted to know if these two also will eat it!?

Thanks for the suggestion!

[prickles]

Another thing I would definitely consider is the MAX size a fish can get. For example, my wife wanted a desardjini sailfin...Adult size is about 1.5'....Now, I could put it in my 8' tank for a while but...At 1.5', It would need a BIG tank. My 4-5" tangs look cramped. I can't realistically say I will ever get a tank big enough to house a fish the size of a cat or small dog. If I had one and had to give it away, who would I give it to that could house it? Remember by the time it is grown, you will love it, but may not be able to afford to keep it. Don't condemn a fish to misery from lack of planning.

I'm not saying you would do that, just a reminder.