Reef Central Online Community

Reef Central Online Community (http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/index.php)
-   Anemones & Clownfish (http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=36)
-   -   How many clownfish can you put in a tank? (http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=1926169)

Bofa 10/28/2010 04:32 PM

How many clownfish can you put in a tank?
 
A. ocellaris and A. percula...How many Clownfish can I add to my tank? I see stores have like a ton of these together.

Thanks :P

davocean 10/28/2010 05:02 PM

One pair unless very short term or from same clutch.

Frogmanx82 10/29/2010 08:22 PM

I have 4 false percs together for 18 months in a 90. Tank raised from the same clutch i think makes a big difference. The standard rule of just one pair certainly applies to wild caught. Tank raised just don't exhibit the same behaviors. Mine have yet to pair off and I haven't seen any eggs though they go through the cleaning behaviors.

davocean 10/29/2010 09:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frogmanx82 (Post 17854688)
Mine have yet to pair off and I haven't seen any eggs though they go through the cleaning behaviors.

When this happens I would expect a change in behavior, and it often happens over night, and often not a pleasant outcome.

velvetelvis 10/30/2010 09:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frogmanx82 (Post 17854688)
I have 4 false percs together for 18 months in a 90. Tank raised from the same clutch i think makes a big difference. The standard rule of just one pair certainly applies to wild caught. Tank raised just don't exhibit the same behaviors. Mine have yet to pair off and I haven't seen any eggs though they go through the cleaning behaviors.

IME, it doesn't matter whether they're WC or CB. For a while I kept four CB pink skunk clownfish (one of the more passive clownfish species), acquired as older juveniles, in a 75. They had no anemone to fight over. They got along until two of them began pairing off, and then the pair began to harass the other two mercilessly until I removed them.

The reason stores are able to keep groups of clownfish together is that these fishes are usually small juveniles. Once those juveniles begin to reach sexual maturity, they'll fight for dominance--and once that's established and they've formed a pair, they'll fight to defend their territory.

jc16 10/31/2010 01:21 AM

how about two different species of clownfishes? i currently have two true perculas but want to add another pair of clarkii later on, it is okay? i have a 300g tank

Frogmanx82 10/31/2010 07:34 AM

I'm not sure mine will ever pair up. Tank raised are not the same as wild caught. 18 months is a pretty long time. At this point even if they do pair up, I feel they have been better off in my tank than with the average nemo fish buyer.

velvetelvis 10/31/2010 07:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jc16 (Post 17859447)
how about two different species of clownfishes? i currently have two true perculas but want to add another pair of clarkii later on, it is okay? i have a 300g tank

Clarkii are brutes. They get big and are very territorial and aggressive. Clownfishes from the clarkii complex also aren't as dependent on their hosts as other clownfish complexes and are stronger swimmers, so they're more prone to roaming all over the tank (and attacking other clowns they encounter on the way). Not a good idea.

elegance coral 10/31/2010 07:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jc16 (Post 17859447)
how about two different species of clownfishes? i currently have two true perculas but want to add another pair of clarkii later on, it is okay? i have a 300g tank

Very, very, very, very risky. Even in a 300. Clarkii's can get large and very nasty. They also claim rather large territories for a clown fish.

velvetelvis 10/31/2010 08:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elegance coral (Post 17859857)
Very, very, very, very risky. Even in a 300. Clarkii's can get large and very nasty. They also claim rather large territories for a clown fish.

A LSF about an hour from me has a pair of chrysopterus (for those new to clownfishes, not a a clarkii, but a member of the clarkii complex) and a large BTA in a 700G display tank. The female is the size of my hand and the undisputed queen of the entire tank, which she patrols regularly. Even the triggerfish hustle out of her way when they see her coming. The store had briefly tried to house a pair of ocellaris in the same system, but had to remove them soon after for their own safety.

jc16 10/31/2010 10:20 PM

okay yea thats what i thought too thanks guys i really like those blue banded clarkii from fiji they are beautiful but i already have a pair of the perculas

reefbegood 11/01/2010 12:33 AM

http://i732.photobucket.com/albums/w...d/IMG_2086.jpg


JUST CLOWNING AROUND!

reefbegood 11/01/2010 12:37 AM

Just a 1 pair per tank for real

davocean 11/01/2010 08:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by reefbegood (Post 17863373)

Those look like all from same clutch, which seems the only way to safely try the multiple clowns gig.
Check Moberts 27 clowns sticky above for an eye popper, but I think she even stated some losses for unknown reasons.

velvetelvis 11/01/2010 09:01 AM

I think even if they're from the same clutch, it will eventually implode...my skunks were all from the same clutch.

ClownNut 11/01/2010 09:37 AM

4 black/white ocellaris. it takes me over 4 years to put this togather. i started with a 3 years old pair, then i added 4 juvens, the big female rejected one of them right away. over the next year, 2 juven pair up and rejected the smallest juven. now all 4(2 pair) living in 5 big rose. they hang out togather and defend the rose togather. i tried put more juvens. all 4 clowns line up and beat the new juvens to the corner. so i removed the juvens and stop adding more. i always want a big happy family of clown, i guess 4 is my #.
big female:3.5"
big male:2.75-3"
small female:2.5"
small male:1.75-2"
they all have been togather over 2 years now. never fight. united against any new comers.

BonsaiNut 11/01/2010 12:28 PM

Do not be mad when I post this, and I am not trying to start a war or anything, but this has to be the single most frequently asked question in this forum. I have no idea how many times it has been asked, discussed and answered over the years.

If you are really interested in an answer, I would recommend checking the FAQ or using the search function.

If you just want to chat, go for it! Not trying to rain on your parade! :)

Frogmanx82 11/01/2010 09:07 PM

I think everyone knows what the rule is. One pair per tank. I think they are looking for people who have been successful breaking the rules so they can do what they want. I bought 4 and its worked out great for a year and a half. If they pair up now and I end up with 2, I was very adequately warned. At this point even the victims likely would have done worse in a tank less well maintained than mine.

kerusso316 11/01/2010 09:31 PM

The biggest problem is more than one female in a tank. You can do several males. I have a 75 gal. With about 60 fish in it. They are from several different clutches. There are several different species of clowns. There is one female. All others male. No death. Note: When fish are fighting to be the female, death will result. When fish fight to be the dominate male fins get shredded a bit.

Frogmanx82 11/01/2010 09:50 PM

No pics of that 75? I'd like to see that many fish in a 75. Well, normally I wouldn't but you seem to take good care of your fish.

TDesaulniers 11/02/2010 12:07 AM

The general rule of thumb is 1 pair per tank. Unless you have an absurd amount of volume, I wouldn't go against the grain and put any more than one pair.

Outerbank 11/02/2010 09:09 PM

I agree on the general rule of 1 pair per tank unless the tank is absolutely huge. I tried adding a second pair to my 240 and the new pair was significantly harassed. They now live in my refugium and the old folks (now 17 years old) still live in the main tank.

bues0022 11/02/2010 10:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kerusso316 (Post 17867441)
The biggest problem is more than one female in a tank. You can do several males. I have a 75 gal. With about 60 fish in it. They are from several different clutches. There are several different species of clowns. There is one female. All others male. No death. Note: When fish are fighting to be the female, death will result. When fish fight to be the dominate male fins get shredded a bit.

Disclaimer: experienced breeder - not for the inexperienced to attempt.

aleonn 11/02/2010 10:24 PM

I really wanted to add one or two black clownfish to my paired false percs in my upcoming 180. Won't take any chances, though.

Ethan_W 11/02/2010 11:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ClownNut (Post 17864198)
4 black/white ocellaris. it takes me over 4 years to put this togather. i started with a 3 years old pair, then i added 4 juvens, the big female rejected one of them right away. over the next year, 2 juven pair up and rejected the smallest juven. now all 4(2 pair) living in 5 big rose. they hang out togather and defend the rose togather. i tried put more juvens. all 4 clowns line up and beat the new juvens to the corner. so i removed the juvens and stop adding more. i always want a big happy family of clown, i guess 4 is my #.
big female:3.5"
big male:2.75-3"
small female:2.5"
small male:1.75-2"
they all have been togather over 2 years now. never fight. united against any new comers.

thats because you probably have 3 males and 1 female. even if their are 2 pairs. females rarely, if ever tolerate each other. if one of your males ever does try to become a female, you'll see a big change


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:58 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.