Quote:
Originally Posted by bertoni
I think people have reported much healthier corals with carbon dosing (in some cases), which implies better growth. Different tanks respond very differently to carbon dosing.
|
A couple thoughts.
Given that the carbon dosing table was incorrecting scaled, might the variable success rate of carbon dosing be partly attributed to underdosing?
Has anyone actually proved that carbon dosing works in aquariums? Might the variable success rate reflect the random results obtained from application of a placebo? I understand the science behind carbon dosing in the aquaculture industry. Where are the scientific studies about carbon dosing in aquaria? Is all the evidence anecdotal?