Reef Central Online Community

Go Back   Reef Central Online Community > General Interest Forums > Lighting, Filtration & Other Equipment
Blogs FAQ Calendar Mark Forums Read

Notices

User Tag List

Reply
Thread Tools
Unread 02/18/2014, 01:59 AM   #1
Western_reefer
Reef keeper
 
Western_reefer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: 70° 17' 59.176"/-83° 6' 27.2768"
Posts: 5,734
What are a few problems with an over-sized skimmer?

What are a few problems with an over-sized skimmer? Say, 4 times the size rating?


__________________
-Moses, the reef/azoox nut.

Food comes with it's own flavor. Anything that has to steal flavor from other food just so it can have flavor is not a food. That is

Current Tank Info: 120 gallon Mixed Reef, mostly SPS dominated
Western_reefer is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 07:25 AM   #2
Drae
RAIDER NATION!
 
Drae's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: City of sin...
Posts: 3,476
Performance. If the skimmer is too large it just plain and simply won't produce any skimmate. Put a 12" diameter skimmer on a 40b and you'll never get any skimmate. You don't want your skimmer to idle for too long imo. It's okay for it to stop producing on occasion but not for a day or two. A properly sized skimmer is best imo. Becketts and tall skimmers are kinda another story though. Most are tall and skinny ( 8" diameter 36" tall beckett extends contact time) and actually work well on a variety of tank sizes but short and stubby needle wheels can easy pass a lot of water through without creating a stable foam head if they're too large for your tanks bio load.


Drae is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 07:35 AM   #3
Uncle Salty 05
Registered Member
 
Uncle Salty 05's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: South Florida
Posts: 3,799
Likely to be louder than desired.


__________________
In all that I endure, of one thing I am sure.
Knowledge and reason, change like the season.
A jester's promenade. - Kerry Livgren

Current Tank Info: 180 gal reef tank with dual attached refugiums 20 long and 10 gallon. Plus 55 gallon True Percula breeding tank.
Uncle Salty 05 is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 08:21 AM   #4
d2mini
Registered Member
 
d2mini's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 10,344
Quote:
Originally Posted by drae View Post
performance. If the skimmer is too large it just plain and simply won't produce any skimmate. Put a 12" diameter skimmer on a 40b and you'll never get any skimmate. You don't want your skimmer to idle for too long imo. It's okay for it to stop producing on occasion but not for a day or two. A properly sized skimmer is best imo. Becketts and tall skimmers are kinda another story though. Most are tall and skinny ( 8" diameter 36" tall beckett extends contact time) and actually work well on a variety of tank sizes but short and stubby needle wheels can easy pass a lot of water through without creating a stable foam head if they're too large for your tanks bio load.
+1


__________________
-dennis

Elos Diamond 120xl | Elos Stand | Radion G4 Pros | GHL Profilux Controller | LifeReef Skimmer | LifeReef Sump
Photos taken with a Nikon D750 or Leica M.
d2mini is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 11:51 AM   #5
Western_reefer
Reef keeper
 
Western_reefer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: 70° 17' 59.176"/-83° 6' 27.2768"
Posts: 5,734
So, at what point would a skimmer be too large? Say, I'm setting up a 75 gallon SPS tank with a very high fish bioload, very very heavy daily feedings(the fish im going to keep will most likely be fed 5-6 times a day, so pretty much small amounts dosed throughout the day), and very very heavy nightly feedings(sun corals, and other non-photosynthetic corals). Would a skimmer rated for 300 gallons be way too large for my 75 gallon crazy bioload tank?


__________________
-Moses, the reef/azoox nut.

Food comes with it's own flavor. Anything that has to steal flavor from other food just so it can have flavor is not a food. That is

Current Tank Info: 120 gallon Mixed Reef, mostly SPS dominated
Western_reefer is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 11:56 AM   #6
d2mini
Registered Member
 
d2mini's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Houston, TX
Posts: 10,344
It might be, but it's hard to say. You can't really trust ANY of the skimmer ratings out there as they are all different and there is no industry standard. So if someone tells you that they are using skimmer A on their tank with really heavy feedings, you have no idea if skimmer B will perform the same way. The best you can do is find someone with the same skimmer running on a very similar tank/bioload, or call and talk to the manufacturer and explain you situation and see what they recommend. I'd probably go with the latter. Find a skimmer you are interested in and then call and talk to someone.

When i bought my LifeReef skimmer, i called and talked to the owner who talked to me for like 30-40 minutes. He was able to recommend the correct size skimmer for my particular setup and I couldn't be happier. I also called and talked to the nice guys at ReefDynamics.


__________________
-dennis

Elos Diamond 120xl | Elos Stand | Radion G4 Pros | GHL Profilux Controller | LifeReef Skimmer | LifeReef Sump
Photos taken with a Nikon D750 or Leica M.
d2mini is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 12:55 PM   #7
Uncle Salty 05
Registered Member
 
Uncle Salty 05's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: South Florida
Posts: 3,799
Any skimmer that has a hose (most newer ones don't) between the pump and reaction chamber can be "dialed in" by adjusting the flow of water and air.


__________________
In all that I endure, of one thing I am sure.
Knowledge and reason, change like the season.
A jester's promenade. - Kerry Livgren

Current Tank Info: 180 gal reef tank with dual attached refugiums 20 long and 10 gallon. Plus 55 gallon True Percula breeding tank.
Uncle Salty 05 is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 03:25 PM   #8
Western_reefer
Reef keeper
 
Western_reefer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: 70° 17' 59.176"/-83° 6' 27.2768"
Posts: 5,734
Quote:
Originally Posted by Drae View Post
Performance. If the skimmer is too large it just plain and simply won't produce any skimmate. Put a 12" diameter skimmer on a 40b and you'll never get any skimmate. You don't want your skimmer to idle for too long imo. It's okay for it to stop producing on occasion but not for a day or two. A properly sized skimmer is best imo. Becketts and tall skimmers are kinda another story though. Most are tall and skinny ( 8" diameter 36" tall beckett extends contact time) and actually work well on a variety of tank sizes but short and stubby needle wheels can easy pass a lot of water through without creating a stable foam head if they're too large for your tanks bio load.
Quote:
Originally Posted by d2mini View Post
It might be, but it's hard to say. You can't really trust ANY of the skimmer ratings out there as they are all different and there is no industry standard. So if someone tells you that they are using skimmer A on their tank with really heavy feedings, you have no idea if skimmer B will perform the same way. The best you can do is find someone with the same skimmer running on a very similar tank/bioload, or call and talk to the manufacturer and explain you situation and see what they recommend. I'd probably go with the latter. Find a skimmer you are interested in and then call and talk to someone.

When i bought my LifeReef skimmer, i called and talked to the owner who talked to me for like 30-40 minutes. He was able to recommend the correct size skimmer for my particular setup and I couldn't be happier. I also called and talked to the nice guys at ReefDynamics.
So, when it comes to going with much higher rated skimmers, narrow and taller skimmers would work better? Say a narrow/tall skimmer rated for 300 gallons would work better than a wide/short skimmer rated for 300 gallons?


__________________
-Moses, the reef/azoox nut.

Food comes with it's own flavor. Anything that has to steal flavor from other food just so it can have flavor is not a food. That is

Current Tank Info: 120 gallon Mixed Reef, mostly SPS dominated
Western_reefer is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 03:41 PM   #9
ridetheducati
20 and Over Club
 
ridetheducati's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Bowie, MD
Posts: 2,968
Quote:
Originally Posted by Western_reefer View Post
So, when it comes to going with much higher rated skimmers, narrow and taller skimmers would work better? Say a narrow/tall skimmer rated for 300 gallons would work better than a wide/short skimmer rated for 300 gallons?
Taller is always better than shorter.

No, that is not what she said.


__________________
"Send more paramedics"

Current Tank Info: 300g DD, SPS dominated, Apex, Tunze 6125s, ATB 1050, 400w MH, and Geo 618 Ca Reactor
ridetheducati is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 04:23 PM   #10
Drae
RAIDER NATION!
 
Drae's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: City of sin...
Posts: 3,476
Quote:
Originally Posted by Western_reefer View Post
So, when it comes to going with much higher rated skimmers, narrow and taller skimmers would work better? Say a narrow/tall skimmer rated for 300 gallons would work better than a wide/short skimmer rated for 300 gallons?
The taller skimmers have more contact time thus making them skimmate producing beasts. There is a con for every pro though... Power consumption, space hogs, noise, maintenance associated with beckett injectors or downdrafts ( excluding life reefs mazzi venturi). Your not getting one of these under a stand so the shorter needle wheel skimmers are designed to be in sump units that work pretty well IF BALANCED WELL.


Drae is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 07:29 PM   #11
Pokerman11
Registered Member
 
Pokerman11's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: North East Ohio
Posts: 221
a lot of factors in play here.

Noise, size and price are the two biggest downsides to over-skimming.

Also as mentioned if you WAY over skim then the skimmer will not produce enough skimmate to work. Lots of skimmers need enough skimmate to push the foam out the top of the cup. If you are WAY over skimming this will not
happen.

However, heavy bio-load and a 300g rates skimmer on your 75G - that should still be okay. Look at the design of the skimmer and determine for yourself.

I run a 300G rated skimmer on my 90g.


Pokerman11 is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 08:21 PM   #12
AcroporAddict
There is no substitute.
 
AcroporAddict's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Southeast
Posts: 2,269
A person with an immense amount of experience with skimmers of all types and Brands is Jeremy from Premium Aquatics. Inconsistent performance is the main issue, taken from his many threads and posts on the topic.

One thing to note is that skimmer ratings are not standardized or anything, and you have to take manufacturer's rating with a grain of salt. I would rather have a skimmer that is evenly matched to my system than one that is too large or too small.

One brand of skimmer that seem to be realistically, if not a bit underrated as to the volume they can handle is the Bubble King line and the Vertex Alpha cone line.

I was going to order a BK SuperMarin 300 internal for my 465 gallon SPS system, and Jeremy steered me towards the smaller, less expensive SuperMarin 250 because he said it is better matched to my system volume than the 300.

I took his advice and changed my order, because, quite frankly, there is probably no one with more hands on experience with protein skimmers than him.

Also, oversized skimmers generally have more powerful pumps, draw more electricity, and have long idle times where they are using electricity but not producing any skimmate. Waste of money vs a properly sized skimmer that always has a foam head on it and uses less electricity.


AcroporAddict is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 08:55 PM   #13
rappyfly
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Toronto, Canada
Posts: 39
I have H&S A200 1260x2 skimmer which rate 550G on my 50G tank before and 40G tank now. Because it is an external skimmer, I can dial in the skimmer easier than internal skimmer and I just use one pump to produce air/water mixture.

Over rate skimmer might remove benefit trace elements faster, but it reduces waste faster which cause algae boom. As of now, I have 20 fishes (include a purple and blue tang) in my 40G than 50G 10 years ago. Big skimmer and nutrition export help on the high load.



Last edited by rappyfly; 02/18/2014 at 09:03 PM.
rappyfly is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 10:50 PM   #14
Western_reefer
Reef keeper
 
Western_reefer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: 70° 17' 59.176"/-83° 6' 27.2768"
Posts: 5,734
Quote:
Originally Posted by AcroporAddict View Post
A person with an immense amount of experience with skimmers of all types and Brands is Jeremy from Premium Aquatics. Inconsistent performance is the main issue, taken from his many threads and posts on the topic.

One thing to note is that skimmer ratings are not standardized or anything, and you have to take manufacturer's rating with a grain of salt. I would rather have a skimmer that is evenly matched to my system than one that is too large or too small.

One brand of skimmer that seem to be realistically, if not a bit underrated as to the volume they can handle is the Bubble King line and the Vertex Alpha cone line.

I was going to order a BK SuperMarin 300 internal for my 465 gallon SPS system, and Jeremy steered me towards the smaller, less expensive SuperMarin 250 because he said it is better matched to my system volume than the 300.

I took his advice and changed my order, because, quite frankly, there is probably no one with more hands on experience with protein skimmers than him.

Also, oversized skimmers generally have more powerful pumps, draw more electricity, and have long idle times where they are using electricity but not producing any skimmate. Waste of money vs a properly sized skimmer that always has a foam head on it and uses less electricity.

Do you think you can give me Jeremys contact information please?


__________________
-Moses, the reef/azoox nut.

Food comes with it's own flavor. Anything that has to steal flavor from other food just so it can have flavor is not a food. That is

Current Tank Info: 120 gallon Mixed Reef, mostly SPS dominated
Western_reefer is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 10:52 PM   #15
Western_reefer
Reef keeper
 
Western_reefer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: 70° 17' 59.176"/-83° 6' 27.2768"
Posts: 5,734
Quote:
Originally Posted by Drae View Post
The taller skimmers have more contact time thus making them skimmate producing beasts. There is a con for every pro though... Power consumption, space hogs, noise, maintenance associated with beckett injectors or downdrafts ( excluding life reefs mazzi venturi). Your not getting one of these under a stand so the shorter needle wheel skimmers are designed to be in sump units that work pretty well IF BALANCED WELL.
I have about 34"-35" of clearance in my stand, so I think I can fit a 32"-33" tall skimmer.. (i have a very tall stand.. lol)


__________________
-Moses, the reef/azoox nut.

Food comes with it's own flavor. Anything that has to steal flavor from other food just so it can have flavor is not a food. That is

Current Tank Info: 120 gallon Mixed Reef, mostly SPS dominated
Western_reefer is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/18/2014, 11:58 PM   #16
AcroporAddict
There is no substitute.
 
AcroporAddict's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Southeast
Posts: 2,269
Quote:
Originally Posted by Western_reefer View Post
Do you think you can give me Jeremys contact information please?
Jeremy is one of the main guys at Premium Aquatics, A Reef Central Sponsor. His screen name is Jeremy B. You can PM him through Reef Central.

They have a Forum in the Sponsor section. Here is a long thread regarding BK skimmers, but there is a lot of general skimmer info in there as well. I am not trying to push you to BK skimmers. There are other good brands as well, but Jeremy will not steer you to something to make money. If you tell him adequate info about your system and stocking levels, he can give you some skimmer options well suited to your reef.

BK Skimmer Club thread:

http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/sh....php?t=1524677

Many other threads about different brands of skimmers on there as well in the Premium Sponsor forum.


AcroporAddict is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/19/2014, 01:25 AM   #17
Western_reefer
Reef keeper
 
Western_reefer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: 70° 17' 59.176"/-83° 6' 27.2768"
Posts: 5,734
Quote:
Originally Posted by AcroporAddict View Post
Jeremy is one of the main guys at Premium Aquatics, A Reef Central Sponsor. His screen name is Jeremy B. You can PM him through Reef Central.

They have a Forum in the Sponsor section. Here is a long thread regarding BK skimmers, but there is a lot of general skimmer info in there as well. I am not trying to push you to BK skimmers. There are other good brands as well, but Jeremy will not steer you to something to make money. If you tell him adequate info about your system and stocking levels, he can give you some skimmer options well suited to your reef.

BK Skimmer Club thread:

http://www.reefcentral.com/forums/sh....php?t=1524677

Many other threads about different brands of skimmers on there as well in the Premium Sponsor forum.
Don't get me wrong, I would LOVE a BK skimmer, I just don't have $1,500 to shed on just a skimmer... If I did, I'd get a BK skimmer... lol

Thanks!!


__________________
-Moses, the reef/azoox nut.

Food comes with it's own flavor. Anything that has to steal flavor from other food just so it can have flavor is not a food. That is

Current Tank Info: 120 gallon Mixed Reef, mostly SPS dominated
Western_reefer is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/19/2014, 02:23 AM   #18
AcroporAddict
There is no substitute.
 
AcroporAddict's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Southeast
Posts: 2,269
Quote:
Originally Posted by Western_reefer View Post
Don't get me wrong, I would LOVE a BK skimmer, I just don't have $1,500 to shed on just a skimmer... If I did, I'd get a BK skimmer... lol

Thanks!!
Like I said, Jeremy will steer you to a Brand that is good for your system and budget. Just PM him. He has experience with many Brands besides BK.

Use the BK thread as a great information source for sizing and general operation of a skimmer, regardless of the Brand.



Last edited by AcroporAddict; 02/19/2014 at 02:30 AM.
AcroporAddict is offline   Reply With Quote
Unread 02/19/2014, 05:42 PM   #19
Timber77
Registered Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 754
I tend to run oversized skimmers and don't have any of the above issues. I run a 6 foot aquamedic t5000 8 inch on a 200 gallon tank a h&s 300 (3 pump 12 inch) on 250 gallon and a bigger atb on a 200 gallon predator tank. I also can feed heavily and rarely lose fish or corals. External skimmers are easier to adjust would go that route imo


Timber77 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On



All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:35 AM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Powered by Searchlight © 2024 Axivo Inc.
Use of this web site is subject to the terms and conditions described in the user agreement.
Reef CentralTM Reef Central, LLC. Copyright ©1999-2022
User Alert System provided by Advanced User Tagging v3.3.0 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.