Stupid noob mistake

[Bulldog39]

Tank started a week ago and haven't gotten a ato yet and wondering why my readings are so strong. Just realized I have evaporated about 1 gallon of water. Just friendly reminder to the other begginers keep up with ro adding till we all have a ato

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[jlmawp]

This is the 3rd thread you’ve made about this. It’s time to relax man. You’re gonna drive yourself crazy. You should use the existing threads you have for this subject.

[JUNBUG361]

Lol

[Bulldog39]

Originally Posted by jlmawp

This is the 3rd thread you’ve made about this. It’s time to relax man. You’re gonna drive yourself crazy. You should use the existing threads you have for this subject.

Thanks for the support know anyone that wants to buy a Tank? If asking questions gets these responses then your right shut off my lights and stuff. Thanks for the advise to quit.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[SammyL]

Originally Posted by Bulldog39

Thanks for the support know anyone that wants to buy a Tank? If asking questions gets these responses then your right shut off my lights and stuff. Thanks for the advise to quit.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

I don't believe he was being mean but just trying to give you some constructive advise.

[jlmawp]

Originally Posted by Bulldog39

Thanks for the support know anyone that wants to buy a Tank? If asking questions gets these responses then your right shut off my lights and stuff. Thanks for the advise to quit.

At no point did I say anything about quitting. You asked similar questions in your other threads, and you got a ton of answers. Accurate answers. You just chose not to listen to them because they weren't the answers you wanted. If you are going to threaten to quit after 4 days, before your tank is even cycled, then maybe you should be thinking about getting rid of it before the real challenge begins. Cycling is the easy part.

This is a hobby of patience and occasional setback. Everyone goes through it...it's part of the learning experience. So far, in the other two threads you have made, people have told you to be patient and let the cycle take its course, including myself. They all say sometimes it takes up to a month. The average cycle is 2-3 weeks. It has been 4 days for your tank. Mcgyver even told you that everything is fine and your situation is totally normal, and he doesn't mince words. Instead of heeding the advice of the experienced people that you are asking advice from, you keep trying to force your way into cycling a tank with chemicals and over-analyzing water level tests. People are trying to tell you how things work, and you aren't listening. Your tank doesn't need more chemicals, treatments, or changes. It needs time. A tank cycle isn't something you get to fast forward. You will learn that there are no healthy shortcuts in this hobby, and it's best to have some more patience and allow things to go slowly and steadily. Trust me on this. Others who are much more experienced than myself will agree. This forum's creed is "nothing good in this hobby happens quickly". You will see it many times if you decide to stick around.

Your tank WILL cycle, and you WILL get to move forward and have a beautiful reef tank with corals, inverts, and fish. Clearly it's important to you, and you seem like you'll pay attention and do a good job. But obsessing over a 4 day cycle is not a good start, and it's not going to make it go any faster. It's just not ready yet, man. It will be ready when it's ready. Leave it alone for a week and it will likely be a lot better. Interfering with tanks too much can cause more issues than it helps. GIVE IT TIME.

I'm not trying to be a jerk, I'm trying to give you some advice, like Sammy said. Don't be so dramatic. You're doing fine, and your tank will be fine. You have everyone here to ask questions to as you go forward, but you have to be able to take advice and understand that people here spout truth and are out for your best interests...even if it's not the thing you necessarily want to hear.

[Tripod1404]

Originally Posted by jlmawp

At no point did I say anything about quitting. You asked similar questions in your other threads, and you got a ton of answers. Accurate answers. You just chose not to listen to them because they weren't the answers you wanted. If you are going to threaten to quit after 4 days, before your tank is even cycled, then maybe you should be thinking about getting rid of it before the real challenge begins. Cycling is the easy part.

This is a hobby of patience and occasional setback. Everyone goes through it...it's part of the learning experience. So far, in the other two threads you have made, people have told you to be patient and let the cycle take its course, including myself. They all say sometimes it takes up to a month. The average cycle is 2-3 weeks. It has been 4 days for your tank. Mcgyver even told you that everything is fine and your situation is totally normal, and he doesn't mince words. Instead of heeding the advice of the experienced people that you are asking advice from, you keep trying to force your way into cycling a tank with chemicals and over-analyzing water level tests. People are trying to tell you how things work, and you aren't listening. Your tank doesn't need more chemicals, treatments, or changes. It needs time. A tank cycle isn't something you get to fast forward. You will learn that there are no healthy shortcuts in this hobby, and it's best to have some more patience and allow things to go slowly and steadily. Trust me on this. Others who are much more experienced than myself will agree. This forum's creed is "nothing good in this hobby happens quickly". You will see it many times if you decide to stick around.

Your tank WILL cycle, and you WILL get to move forward and have a beautiful reef tank with corals, inverts, and fish. Clearly it's important to you, and you seem like you'll pay attention and do a good job. But obsessing over a 4 day cycle is not a good start, and it's not going to make it go any faster. It's just not ready yet, man. It will be ready when it's ready. Leave it alone for a week and it will likely be a lot better. Interfering with tanks too much can cause more issues than it helps. GIVE IT TIME.

I'm not trying to be a jerk, I'm trying to give you some advice, like Sammy said. Don't be so dramatic. You're doing fine, and your tank will be fine. You have everyone here to ask questions to as you go forward, but you have to be able to take advice and understand that people here spout truth and are out for your best interests...even if it's not the thing you necessarily want to hear.

I agree, having success with this hobby requires patience and the ability accept criticism/advise. If you "force" stuff and ignore advises that you dont want to hear, quitting would be a better option than spending couple of thousand dollars and hundreds of hours for an eventual failure.

Also as an advise, evaporation of 1 gallon water from 40 gallons would not move any parameter much. It would concentrate them only by 2.5% (lets say 3% since real volume likely is lower than 40). So it would raise 10 ppm nitrate to ~10.3 ppm. I change smaller than the resolution of hobby grade tests.

[rocsec1]

Ato’s are great but I went a year without one. Just got in the habit of topping the water off every other day. It got be a pain so I got the ato. You can have a successful tank without it but it is more work.

[Bulldog39]

Originally Posted by rocsec1

Ato’s are great but I went a year without one. Just got in the habit of topping the water off every other day. It got be a pain so I got the ato. You can have a successful tank without it but it is more work.

Got one coming in 3 days. I'm forgetful about it

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[hkgar]

Originally Posted by rocsec1

Ato’s are great but I went a year without one. Just got in the habit of topping the water off every other day. It got be a pain so I got the ato. You can have a successful tank without it but it is more work.

I went 12 years without one.

[Cancun]

Hi there.....I agree with others here....no need to quit....this hobby has taught me a HUGE lesson in patience.....Also is always room for improvement....and coming on here asking questions is the best way to get help. We have all been there and done that. Just sit back and enjoy the whole experience! ��

[trembz]

6 years no ato..
Just set up a routine
I.e. do top off when you feed fish in the morning

Sent from my SM-G935W8 using Tapatalk

[sde1500]

I used to forget to top off a lot. Was warned to add water when the return pump started sucking air. Now I have an ATO that I forget to fill up. Am reminded when the ATO pump starts sucking air. I like the convenience for sure though.

[James404]

Originally Posted by Bulldog39

Got one coming in 3 days. I'm forgetful about it

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

Good job getting an ATO, it definitely makes life easier.

There's lots of ups and downs in this hobby, the key is to learn from your mistakes and keep moving forward.

[Bulldog39]

Originally Posted by James404

Good job getting an ATO, it definitely makes life easier.

There's lots of ups and downs in this hobby, the key is to learn from your mistakes and keep moving forward.

Yeah that's why I ask so many questions. Makes some mad but when worded differently I get a better selection of answers sometimes.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G935A using Tapatalk

[NS Mike D]

here is the thing about reef gadgets. Sooner or later they will fail. Whether it's a snail crawling where it shouldn't, software failure or just plain salt wear and tear, plan on it faling at some point in time.

Make sure your ATO has some redundancies for when it will not turn on or even worse, not turn off.